58 W. 56th Street
New York, NY 10019
*Disclaimer: We were not paid for this review. All opinions are our own and based on our personal experience. Your experience may be different.
If you are visiting Times Square or any Midtown attractions, there is a great local Indian restaurant I recommend checking out.Bengal Tiger is a great pick if you are looking for something a bit different than standard American fare. It's a trendy place and a great date night pick. The trendy crowd, great prix-fixe dinner specials, and eclectic ambiance, make it a very popular foodie destination. While the food was a bit too spicy for my taste buds, I really loved the ambiance and sleek decor.
Bengal Tiger is most known for their prix-fixe lunch and dinner menu. For just over 20 bucks, you can enjoy an appetizer, entree, and dessert. Selections include popular appetizers like samosas and pakoras, Vegetarian, Lamb, and Chicken based entrees, as well as a choice between honeyed dumplings or rice pudding for dessert (go with the rice pudding!).
Although the food was a bit too spicy for my taste (even though I ordered mild!), the Saag Paneer and Tikki Masala were still pretty good. While far from the best Indian food I've ever had, the dinner deal is a real steal. The Mulligatawny Soup (not available as part of the deal) really was the highlight of the meal. The Naan (unfortunately, also not included) was also well worth the few extra bucks.
Of course, you also have the option of ordering from the regular menu. As the dinner deal is the best value, I recommend choosing one of the specials and adding a few sides or apps!
Update: The prix-fixe is now priced at $27 as of 2025.
Service was very professional here. My entree was way too spicy for my taste, and the waiter kindly remade the dish without any problem. Unfortunately, it was still way too spicy for my taste buds!
The vibe here is young and modern. The crowd seems to be diverse and energetic. This is a fun choice for anyone looking for an energetic place to meet up with friends or take a date. The interior is dim and features stylish decor. The space is very small, and thus, the wait can be super long on busy weekends. Also, don't go in looking for a quiet romantic meal: this place is noisy and bustling!
Bengal Tiger is one of the better choices for quality authentic Indian food in Midtown. If you are craving Indian and will be in the area, you may as well give it a shot. Anyone who prefers their food spicy will love this place! The pricing is quite affordable, the ambiance is very nice, and the menu filled with all the traditional Indian favorites. Don't leave without treating yourself to their delicious rice pudding!
