Restaurant Reivew

Pizza Pie Cafe

240 2nd E
Rexburg, ID 83440
(208) 359-1123
Five Stars
Main Photo

Pizza Pie Cafe is a pizza buffet restaurant located in Rexburg, Idaho. There are additional locations scattered around Idaho and Utah. It is an all you cat eat buffet which features pizza, a salad, and pasta bar.


I don't eat pizza but I enjoyed the salad buffet, bread sticks and pasta. The salad buffet at this location was not as large as the Pocatello or Ammon location, which was a disappointment. There are 3 different pasta sauces available and several varieties of noodles, including gluten free.

I had a coupon for a buy one get one free buffet from the Idaho Falls Magazine. I recommend checking for coupons each month. Teton Adz also frequently has coupons available. Lunch buffet price: $7.25 Dinner buffet price: $8.25


This is a self service buffet restaurant. One area that could be improved upon is restocking the buffet. Sometimes you have to wait a while for them to put out new pizzas.


This is a casual buffet, it had an Italian restaurant type feel with the checkerboard table cloths. This location actually had the best seating out of the 3 locations I have visited.

Final Remarks

Pizza Pie Cafe is worth a stop, especially if you find a coupon. You will love this restaurant if you are a pizza fan as they have over 10 different varieties available including dessert pizzas. Unlimited food offered at a small price tag is the best way to describe Pizza Pie Cafe.

Pizza Pie Cafe on Urbanspoon