Show Mobile Menu
Restaurant Review
Pizza Pie Cafe
4141 Pole line Road
Pocatello, ID 83201
Restaurant Website
Five Stars Five Stars Five Stars Five Stars Five Stars
Main Photo

Pizza Pie Café is a pizza buffet restaurant, which has locations in Utah and Idaho. In addition to over 10 different types of pizza, there is also a salad buffet, pasta bar, and breadsticks.


I am not a big pizza fan; however, the pizza seemed a bit dry to me. The salad bar here was decent with plenty of toppings available. I didn’t like the breadsticks and the pasta was just average. My boyfriend really liked the dessert pizzas; I am not a fan of sweets so I didn't try any. The food here is not spectacular, but it is a good place to go for a cheap lunch buffet. Check the website as they often offer coupons. There are also coupons available in the "Teton Adz" magazine. The lunch buffet runs $7.25 and the dinner buffet runs $8.25.

Checkout other restaurant reviews from ID!

ID Restaurant Reviews


There is no waiter service here. This is a self-serve restaurant, including drinks.


Employees did a pretty good job of refilling the pizzas and salad toppings despite the number of people. The salad bar area looked clean and fresh.

Restaurant Photo

Final Remarks

Overall, I was not impressed with this buffet. It would be nice if they offered more vegetarian pizza options. I would go here again primarily just for the salad bar (only if I have a coupon). I rated this restaurant a bit higher because of the easy accessibility of coupons.

Pizza Pie Cafe on Foodio54
Pizza Pie Cafe on Urbanspoon